Breaking the Language BaWhy Video Games Aren't Enough to Master English
By Author Giljonnys Dias da Silva
In the modern world, video games have become a central part of entertainment, and many players across the globe, including Brazilians, use them as a way to learn or practice English. With games becoming more immersive and offering dialogues, instructions, and narratives in English, it’s understandable why some believe that playing video games could help people become fluent in the language. However, despite the advantages they offer, video games alone will not make Brazilians fluent in English. To truly master the language, other methods like watching TV stations, listening to music, and tuning into radio stations in English are essential.
Video Games: A Limited Tool for Language Acquisition
Video games can certainly expose players to English vocabulary, particularly with words related to action, strategy, and the game’s narrative. This exposure can help players understand basic phrases, commands, and even some slang. However, the problem lies in the fact that video games are typically designed with entertainment as their primary goal, not language learning.
In many games, the language used is often context-specific, meaning that it’s limited to the game’s universe. For example, players might learn words related to fighting, weaponry, or specific in-game settings, but they might miss out on more conversational language or vocabulary needed for real-life interactions. Furthermore, video games are often focused on action, leaving little room for meaningful dialogue or complex grammar structures. Even games with a narrative element may not provide enough depth or repetition of useful phrases for the learner to internalize the language effectively.
Moreover, video games are often played in short bursts, meaning the language exposure is fragmented. Fluent language acquisition typically requires consistent, real-life practice with varied language contexts, something that video games are not always able to offer.
Watching TV Stations: A Rich Source of Language Input
In contrast to video games, watching TV shows, series, and movies in English provides a richer and more varied language environment. When watching TV, learners are exposed to natural conversations, diverse accents, idiomatic expressions, cultural references, and a broader range of topics. Shows like news programs, talk shows, or scripted series feature real-world language use, which is crucial for understanding how English is spoken in various situations—whether in casual chats, professional settings, or even in formal debates.
When watching TV in English, Brazilians are exposed to colloquial speech, body language, and the context in which certain phrases or words are used, which can enhance their understanding of the language. Furthermore, watching English media helps learners improve their listening skills by hearing different pronunciations, accents, and even regional dialects. This variety is something video games rarely offer, as they often feature more simplified language and limited voice acting.
Listening to Music: A Fun and Effective Way to Learn English
Music, too, plays a significant role in language acquisition. English-language songs provide an excellent opportunity for Brazilians to familiarize themselves with pronunciation, rhythm, and intonation. Lyrics often showcase common phrases, idiomatic expressions, and even slang that people commonly use in informal conversations. By repeatedly listening to songs, learners can pick up on words and phrases they may not encounter in textbooks or formal lessons.
Moreover, songs often tell stories, express emotions, and cover a wide range of subjects—everything from love and relationships to politics or social issues. This wide variety ensures that learners are exposed to different registers of English, from casual language to more formal expressions.
One key benefit of music is its ability to help with memorization. Catchy tunes and repetitive lyrics make it easier for learners to retain new vocabulary. Singing along with the lyrics also improves pronunciation and listening skills. For Brazilians, this can be an enjoyable and engaging way to immerse themselves in the language outside the classroom or game environment.
Radio Stations: Continuous Exposure to Real-Life English
Listening to radio stations in English can complement other forms of language learning, providing Brazilians with a continuous flow of English throughout the day. Radio stations often feature discussions, news, weather forecasts, advertisements, and even phone-in segments with listeners. This diversity exposes learners to a wide range of vocabulary and real-world conversational language. Unlike video games or even TV shows, radio presents the language in a more spontaneous, unpredictable, and conversational manner.
Tuning into radio stations also helps with improving listening comprehension, as learners must focus on understanding language without the visual context provided by TV. This skill is particularly important for real-life communication, where body language and visual cues are not always present. Additionally, radio can expose learners to diverse regional accents and vocabulary, something that is usually missing in video games.
The Importance of Integrating Multiple Language Exposure Methods
To truly become fluent in English, Brazilians need a multi-faceted approach that combines different types of language exposure. Video games alone cannot offer the depth or consistency required for fluency. Instead, learners should integrate different forms of media into their daily routines. Watching English TV shows and movies, listening to music, and tuning into English radio stations all offer complementary ways to absorb the language and improve various aspects of language acquisition.
It’s also crucial for Brazilians to engage with English in practical, everyday contexts. While video games can teach some vocabulary, they do not necessarily prepare players for real-world conversations. Watching TV, listening to music, and tuning into radio stations expose learners to the language as it is used in a variety of settings—helping them become comfortable with both formal and informal language, as well as different accents and cultural nuances.
In conclusion, while video games can be a fun and engaging way to pick up certain aspects of the English language, they are not enough to make Brazilians fluent. For true language acquisition, it’s essential to embrace a holistic approach that includes diverse forms of media, such as TV shows, music, and radio stations. These methods offer a richer, more immersive experience that enhances listening, comprehension, vocabulary acquisition, and cultural understanding. To become fluent in English, Brazilians must expand their exposure to the language beyond the confines of video games and immerse themselves in the full spectrum of English-language media.
Bibliographic References
Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind in Society: The Development of Higher Psychological Processes. Harvard University Press.
Vygotsky’s theories on social interaction and the role of language in cognitive development can be applied to understanding the immersive aspects of media, including video games and TV, in language acquisition.
Krashen, S. D. (1982). Principles and Practice in Second Language Acquisition. Pergamon.
Stephen Krashen’s input hypothesis argues that language learners acquire language most effectively when they are exposed to comprehensible input. This theory supports the idea that watching TV, listening to music, and engaging with media in the target language can be beneficial for language acquisition.
Gee, J. P. (2003). What Video Games Have to Teach Us About Learning and Literacy. Computers in the Schools, 20(3-4), 1-23.
James Paul Gee discusses the potential of video games in supporting literacy and learning, exploring how they create immersive environments for players. This article provides insights into how video games can be used to enhance language learning, though with limitations.
Lantolf, J. P., & Thorne, S. L. (2006). Sociocultural Theory and the Genesis of Second Language Development. Oxford University Press.
This book delves into the social and cultural aspects of language learning, providing a theoretical framework for understanding how immersion in various forms of media (including TV, music, and radio) can enhance language development.
Rixon, S. (2013). Listening in the Language Classroom. Cambridge University Press.
This book focuses on the importance of listening skills in language learning, which are crucial when engaging with media like TV, music, and radio. It emphasizes the role of listening to native speakers in fostering understanding and fluency.
Thorne, S. L., & Payne, S. (2005). Evolutionary trajectories, Internet-mediated expression, and language education. CALICO Journal, 22(3), 371-397.
This article explores the intersection of digital media and language learning, touching upon the impact of digital tools and online environments, including video games, in second language acquisition.
Michaud, J., & Willingham, D. (2011). How Watching TV Can Help You Learn English. Foreign Language Annals, 44(2), 205-221.
This paper discusses how watching TV shows can help language learners with vocabulary acquisition, listening skills, and cultural understanding, supporting the idea that exposure to real-world language contexts through TV can be an effective learning method.
Brown, H. D. (2007). Principles of Language Learning and Teaching (5th ed.). Pearson Longman.
Brown’s work on language learning theories and methodologies includes a discussion on input, interaction, and the role of media in language acquisition. It aligns with the idea that TV, music, and radio stations contribute to meaningful language exposure.
Murphey, T. (1992). Music and Song. Oxford University Press.
Murphey explores how music and songs can be used to enhance language learning, particularly in developing listening skills, pronunciation, and vocabulary acquisition in a fun, memorable way.
Mendelsohn, D. (1994). Learning to Listen: A Strategy-Based Approach for the Second Language Learner. San Diego: Dominie Press.
This book emphasizes the role of listening in language acquisition, offering strategies for improving comprehension through active engagement with real-world media, including music, radio, and TV.